3rd March 2020
It has been a while since I last provided an update in my role as Chairperson of the Silkmen Supporters Trust so here goes.
From: Andy Worth [mailto:firstname.lastname@example.org]
Sent: 19 February 2020 13:50
To: Mark Rowan <email@example.com>; John Nagle <JNagle@efl.com>
Subject: A request for a further face to face meeting with the Silkmen Supporters Trust
Dear Mark & John.
I write to you in my role as the Chairperson of the Silkmen Supporters Trust (SST). We are of course aware that Macclesfield Town Football Club (MTFC) has appealed the six points deduction handed out in December 2019 regarding non payment of wages and failure to fulfil a fixture with Crewe Alexandra, and that MTFC have been further charged with misconduct in relation to having the game against Plymouth Argyle on 21st December 2019 postponed as a consequence of having received a ‘zero capacity notice’ by the local Safety Advisory Group.
We completely understand the importance of confidentiality whilst appeals / misconduct charges are heard. However, I am sure that you will both recognise and understand the significant angst of our supporters, who are of the understanding that MTFC had no legal representation at the last hearing which would clearly have placed the club at great disadvantage during the proceedings. Silkmen supporters have received scant information since this time leaving them feeling ‘like mushrooms left in the dark’ and are very concerned not only with regards to our future tenure in the English Football League (EFL) which we are intensely proud of; but indeed regarding our long term future as a small football club with an illustrious history that has significant prestige within the local community in and around Macclesfield.
We recognise that the SST has no ‘locus standi’ and so cannot effectively be directly involved in any hearing, but are most willing to provide any support that we can to help to resolve these matters both professionally and amicably. We would be most pleased for my fellow SST board members John Abbott, Robert Wilson & I to discuss issues of concern to us in the same open and professional manner as they were when we last met in December 2019, and I would like to take this opportunity to advise you that we the SST have formally instructed a solicitor to help us to look after our position. The contact details for our nominated solicitor are highlighted below.
As a consequence of the email my fellow SST board member Richard Pattrick and I spoke with Mark Rowan (Communications’ Director for the EFL) and Andy Andrew Pomfret (Supporter Services Manager for the EFL) in a conference call last Monday afternoon. Whilst clearly recognising the parameters of confidentiality the context of our discussion is highlighted below:
Chairperson of the Silkmen Supporters Trust
23rd January 2020
Super Silk Lotto Announcement
The Super Silk Lotto are delighted to announce that from the draw on 7th February 2020 onwards, all proceeds from this lottery will now be distributed to the Silkmen Supporters Trust (SST).
The lottery will remain the same in all other aspects, still giving you the chance to win £100 every week for only a £1 stake.
The commitment to the community will also remain strong, with a percentage of the yearly proceeds supporting a local community group or charity. Previous partners who have benefitted include David Lewis, Ollie’s Army, Space4Autism, Silklife Foodbank and Phase Onbe Training, which is the charity arm of Canalside Radio.
Whilst proceeds will no longer go directly to Macclesfield Town FC (MTFC), the SST is run for the majority benefit of MTFC and will continue to provide funds with supporters interests at heart. This change makes payments simpler and makes it easier for fans to have a say on where the proceeds go.
Since inception in November 2014, the Super Silk Lotto has gained over 300 entries, paid out over £25,000 in prizes and raised over £32,000 for Macclesfield Town FC. The more members we have, the more money we can raise for our beloved Silkmen and for the local community.
For information on how to join the Super Silk Lotto please visit https://www.sstrust.uk/fundraising/super-silk-lotto/ or if you have any queries, email firstname.lastname@example.org.
Robert, Andy & Marie
Super Silk Lotto Management Team
20th January 2020
The Silkmen Supporters Trust (SST) were heartened by the news at the recent High Court Hearing on Wednesday 15th January 2020 that the winding up order was adjourned once again; and this time for 10 weeks, following the revelation in court that Macclesfield Town majority shareholder Amar AlKadhi had agreed to the sale of the football club, with proof of funds demonstrated.
However we were less encouraged by the subsequent press release by Mr. AlKadhi who spoke of how he would like to progress the sale of Macclesfield Town FC in ‘a timely manner’ and that that he would ‘work tirelessly’ until a sale is complete.
We the SST have held regular dialogue with two of the potential bidders, and recent communications with them since the High Court hearing would appear to be in direct contrast with Mr. AlKadhi’s statement; thus fuelling our concerns of delaying tactics by Mr. AlKadhi to ensure a prolonged extension of the winding up order.
Whilst we are aware that a Non-Disclosure Agreement was made with at least one of the potential bidders, it would be most helpful to know if Mr. AlKadhi has made any direct contact with the English Football League (EFL) regarding the sale of the football club; and if he has shown proof of the offer that has been made.
As a consequence, we have emailed the EFL in an attempt to clarify if this is indeed the case and look forward to a prompt response from them.
In view of the information earlier this afternoon regarding a further misconduct charge (as a consequence of the non fulfilment of the Plymouth Argyle fixture in December) we would urge Mr. AlKadhi to conclude the takeover deal as soon as possible. This would allow the opportunity for Mark Kennedy, Danny Whitaker & Danny Butterfield to bring in reinforcements to strengthen the squad like many clubs around us have already done in this transfer window, and provide us with the best possible opportunity to remain one of the elite 92 clubs in English football.
I would like to take this opportunity to offer a sincere debt of gratitude to SST board member Richard Pattrick, who gave of his time and effort to provide some eyes and ears on behalf of Silkmen fans everywhere during the High Court hearing earlier this week. Please be assured that is the intention of the SST to ensure to employ a similar approach at the next High Court hearing on Wednesday 25th March 2020.
#OUR TOWN#OUR CLUB
Chairperson of the Silkmen Supporters Trust
15th January 2020
This morning the SST had an observer in court 1, Rolls Building London. The Judge was ICC Judge Mullen.
The case was adjourned for 10 weeks as it was uncontested by HMRC. The reason given was that there had been several offers for the club. One has been accepted and there is proof of funds. The sale of the shares has still to be finalised.
We are looking forward to hearing from Mr Alkhadi very quickly on the prospective completion date of the sale.
9th January 2020
Silkmen Supporters Trust Crowdfunder Update
‘An additional route has now been set up for donations – Crowdfunder. It is still more cost effective ( no charges) and easier to access funds quickly by using the bank transfer details ( as per below).
However, for those who would prefer to use Crowdfunder please do so using the following the link below.
At Present the fund stands at :-
Current donations to the SST Hardship fund £13,011.00
New Crowdfunder Page donations £ 556.00
Total Fund £13,567.00
7th January 2020
The SST is delighted to welcome three new members to the Board as a result of the recent Annual General Meeting.
The new Board members are:-
Mr. Rob Wilson who has taken up the position of Secretary
Mr Patrick Birch, Mr Bryan Brown,, Mr Michael Clark, Mrs Caroline Harrop, and
Mr Jon Mail have become Board Members..
We look forward to their contributions to the Silkmen Supporters Trust.
4th January 2020
The Silkmen Supporters Trust (SST) board were deeply saddened by the recent news of the resignations of Daryl McMahon and Steve Gritt, and I am sure that I speak for the overwhelming majority of Silkmen fans in wishing both Daryl and Steve all the very best for the future wherever this may take them, and with an assurance that they will always a very warm welcome should they ever return to the Moss Rose.
Both Daryl and Steve (alongside Silkmen legend Danny Whitaker) have consistently demonstrated incredible professionalism and integrity throughout their time at the helm of our beloved club despite a wholly preventable yet appalling plethora of off the field circumstances, the most recent of which was the last minute cancellations by Mr. AlKadhi of travel and match preparations for the recent away fixtures against Forest Green Rovers and Port Vale.
It is also our understanding that despite recent media comments that all playing staff, player management and non-playing staff of Macclesfield Town Football Club had been paid in full and on time, that this was not the case. As a consequence, it appears apparent to we; the SST board, that Mr. AlKadhi no longer possesses the resources, financial acumen or integrity to support the club in the long term. We are of the belief that Mr. AlKadhi’s tenure at Macclesfield Town is now at an end, and selling the club as soon as practicable is the only viable option.
The SST board have been in regular contact with two very interested parties in recent weeks in fervent attempts to help broker a deal that will safeguard the future of our club. I am sure you can appreciate, they have not found Mr. AlKadhi particularly helpful, and concerns have been expressed that during January 2020, that Mr. AlKadhi will sell our most saleable assets in terms of players; keep for himself the solidarity payment from the English Premier League of around £225,000,and leave our beloved club high and dry and with little chance of any long term future.
The SST board have made contact with the English Premier League, English Football League (EFL) and the Professional Footballers Association (PFA) in an attempt to ensure that any incoming monies are available only for the benefit of Macclesfield Town Football Club, and are not channelled elsewhere. A copy of the email sent to Richard Masters; Chief Executive of the English Premier League is highlighted below:
Dear Mr. Masters
I am the current Chairperson of the Silkmen Supporters Trust (SST) and write to you in my capacity in this role.
You may have seen some of the adverse publicity surrounding our much loved club. This relates to such issues as regular non-payment / late payment of wages to players and staff which has led to strike action on several occasions that led to the heartbreak of being knocked out of the FA Cup first round after fielding a mixture of youth team and loan players, and non-fulfilment of a fixture against Crewe Alexandra. As a consequence the club was deducted 6 points with a further 4 points suspended due to non fulfillment of fixtures, financial irregularities including late / non payment of wages to players and staff as well as late / non payment to other creditors which also includes football creditors. This has been compounded only last weekend, by the postponement of our match against Plymouth Argyle due to a zero capacity notice issued against our Moss Rose ground by the Safety Advisory Group. It is also of use to note the club have been in the High Court on a number of occasions recently with HMRC issuing winding up orders for non payment of PAYE. The latest matter has been deferred to the middle of January 2020.
It is our understanding that the English Football League (EFL) have been working with the Professional Footballers’ Association (PFA) and redirecting "central funds" to ensure players and staff are receiving some monies but with another pay day due before the end of December the players and staff are again wondering if they will be getting paid. As I am sure you can imagine this is of great concern to the players; particularly at this time of year. It is our view that the issues above are as a direct result of the majority shareholder Amar AlKadhi, who is in our opinion overseeing the demise and destruction of our club. Several Trust Board members and I met with Mark Rowan and John Nagle of the EFL several weeks ago where we shared our concerns, and a conference call was held with them only yesterday.
We are aware that the Premier League make Solidarity Payments to EFL Clubs twice a year and in normal circumstances we believe that Maccclesfield Town would receive £225,000 early in the new year. The purpose of me writing to you is to provide an earnest plea to you to withhold this payment as we fear that if it is made it will just be taken out of the club by Mr. AlKadhi for his own purposes and it will not be used to support the business that is Macclesfield Town Football Club. We also wonder if these funds could possibly be redirected to an appropriate source in order to ensure that the monies can be used directly for the benefit of Macclesfield Town Football Club. We therefore respectfully request your careful consideration of our plea to withhold the Solidarity payment.
May I take this opportunity to wish you a very happy Christmas and New Year, and thank you for taking the time to read my email.
Should you wish to contact me, my mobile number is: **********
Chairperson of the Silkmen Supporters Trust
We will of course provide any pertinent updates, and please be assured that we will continue to lobby all relevant individuals in pursuit of the objective of ensuring the long term future of Macclesfield Town Football Club that is under the custodianship of an individual/s who care about it’s importance not for financial gain, but with regards to its importance as an integral aspect of the cultural heritage of the town of Macclesfield.
We will also work relentlessly to ensure that local and national media coverage is given to ensure that the issues surrounding our club remains firmly in the public eye.
We believe that it is totally unacceptable that Mr. AlKadhi continues to remain virtually silent on the highlighted issues, and are of the view that as a sole director (in law) that Mr. AlKadhi has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the company. The SST board have subsequently taken the opportunity to approach a number of shareholders with a shareholding in excess of 5% to encourage them to request an Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) which would effectively ensure the presence of Mr. AlKadhi to answer appropriately probing questions from other shareholders about how well (or not) the club is being managed.
What we cannot understand is how a club with one of the smallest budgets in the EFL can perform so woefully as a business when it effectively receives over a million pounds a year from the EFL and English Premier League before even taking into account of revenue from gate receipts, sponsorship etc. It is of use to note that the SST are also seeking legal advice from someone who has experience in legislative issues within the world of football and have regularly liaised (and will continue to do so) with Cheshire East Councillors and Member of Parliament for Macclesfield (David Rutley) in our quest for a successful and viable future for Macclesfield Town Football Club.
There really does appear to be no right and wrong answer as to whether people attend or boycott football matches at the Moss Rose at this present time. It really is a matter of personal choice, although it is of use to note that both of the interested parties that the SST board have spoken with, have urged supporters to attend games in support of the players, management and non-playing staff who have been so magnificent in such adverse circumstances during this very difficult period.
What is much more important is that there is no in-fighting between our loyal fan base as this only plays into the hands of Mr. AlKadhi. We must stand as one in our fight for OUR football club that would ultimately be in the hands of a custodian that recognises how precious OUR football club is to so many people.
With this in mind, I urge you to lobby your local councillors / Member of Parliament, and never lose sight of the fact that we may lose some battles along the way, but if we work together we WILL win the war!
Silkmen Supporters Trust Board Members
The S.S.T. would not exist without your support. Please join us and help to make a difference to your football club. You can find the forms that you need to join here.
The Silkmen Supporters’ Trust is committed to the improvement and development of Macclesfield FC by working in partnership with the Club, the fans and the community to the mutual benefit of all.
Silkmen Supporters' Trust
c/o SST Secretary
3 Lincoln Place
If you have ideas about fundraising for SST, projects that SST could get involved in or suggestions for the website please contact SST via our Contact page
Member of the Football Supporters Association